which boy would you rather choose(very tough)

boy 1: extremely attractive, white, light brown hair, 6’0, lean athletic sporty guy, perfect smile and teeth, smart and very sweet and respectful and treats women better than almost any guy you’ve ever met, seems like the perfect guy, feels like a boyfriend.

boy 2: your longtime BF from highschool, long black curly hair, mexican, plays football, cute but in a silly way, 5’11 very loud and outgoing personality, really funny and makes you laugh constantly, feels like a brother sometimes though but remember you love him still.